Fear that the gold shares will never again outperform gold. Doubt that management will ever realize through capital gains or dividend increases the reserves in the ground.
Fear and doubt are the weapons of the gold share short sellers. As long as fear and doubt can be raised to the level of action (selling), aggressive naked shorting can slow the advance of many well run and financed gold companies.
Correlation analysis of the gold stocks relative to gold reveals how fear and doubt were pushed to extremes in 2009. The historically strong correlation between the gold stocks and gold during secular bull advances, such as 1929-1942 and 1968-1980, had fallen well below 0.80 by the end of 2009. This distortion is better revealed by bisecting the latest secular advance. The correlation between the gold stocks and gold had fallen to -0.14 since 2006. This reading suggest no correlation between the two assets and an extreme 'loosening' of tight correlation, 0.95, displayed from 2000 to 2006. The die of “fear and doubt” had been cast to create a tool for the short sellers to use against the weak hands.
Historical Correlation Gold Stocks and Gold Through 2009.12
Once investors were lured in by this contradictory, short-term “lesson”, the market has quietly begun (re)teaching its historical relationship. The loosening of historically tight correlation between the gold stocks and gold from 2006 to 2009 has been quietly reversed in 2010. The correlation has gone from -0.14 to 0.42 over the past ten months. While gold stock investors are likely still behaving in terms of the previous short-term lesson characterized by fear and doubt of holding gold shares within a secular gold bull market, the movement of capital has already adapted.
Historical Correlation Gold Stocks and Gold Through 2010.10
The correlation between gold stocks and gold has and will always be tight and profitable for investors owning well-run and financed gold companies.